The Best Way to Convert Your Loose Coins Into Cash
HomeHome > News > The Best Way to Convert Your Loose Coins Into Cash

The Best Way to Convert Your Loose Coins Into Cash

Mar 09, 2024

Our expert, award-winning staff selects the products we cover and rigorously researches and tests our top picks. If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Reviews ethics statement

You can still convert change into bills for free -- if you know where to go.

Turning your loose change into cash can really pay off.

Turning coins in for cash means a little extra pocket money for most of us. But if you've got enough change lying around, it could make a dent in your rent or even help pay for a trip.

Jeff Stotsky and his husband, Jon Schweizer, regularly drop their loose change into an empty 25-gallon water-cooler jug. When the bottle is full, Stotsky takes it to their credit union to cash out in a Coinstar machine.

"I have to make a bunch of trips because they limit you to $500 per coin dump," Stotsky said. Because he went to a machine at his credit union, he didn't have to waste time rolling coins and, more importantly, he was not charged a fee."One time, we wound up with about $2,400, which helped pay for a trip to Disney World," he said.

If you've been feeling the pinch of inflation -- and who hasn't? -- you might be looking for untapped revenue sources. If you're looking to turn your spare change into a real payday, here's how to get started.

A lot of supermarkets have coin-sorting machines but almost all charge a service fee. (CoinStar's processing fee, for example, is currently 11.9% of whatever you convert, or $11.90 for every $100 in change.) If you go to a Coinstar at a bank or credit union where you have an account, this fee is usually waived.

"A lot of banks have gotten rid of their coin-sorting machines, or consolidated them -- so maybe one out of every five branches has one," Steve Kenneally, senior vice president of payments at the American Bankers Association, told CNET. "It's definitely worth calling ahead before you walk in with a big bag of change." Regional institutions, like Republic Bank in the Mid-Atlantic area and West Virginia's Hancock County Savings Bank, are more likely to still have sorting machines.

If your financial institution doesn't have a machine you should still be able to deposit coins, though it means you'll probably have to put them into rolls. (Many banks will give you free roll papers or you can buy them at Staples or Office Depot.)

Most banks only take coins from people with accounts, or charge nonmembers a percentage. Wells Fargo will turn change into cash for nonmembers for free, but only up to a certain amount.

Rolling coins is tedious but a coin-rolling machine, like a battery-operated coin sorter from Royal Sovereign ($26.99 at Walmart), makes the process a lot faster. If you're sitting on $220 in loose change, using a Coinstar at the grocery store would take that much in fees from you, anyway.If you do plan to bring rolls of coins to a bank or credit union, call ahead to find out their specific policies.

Coinstar typically takes 11.9% from whatever you deposit into the machine.

While there are different coin-sorting machines, Coinstar is by far the most common, with more than 60,000 kiosks in North America, Western Europe and Japan that sift through more than $2.7 billion in change each year.

Major chains like CVS, Target, Safeway, ShopRite and Walmart often have Coinstar machines near the front of the store. You can also check the Coinstar website for a location near you. Typically, you (carefully) feed your change into the machine and wait while it tallies up your total, while sorting out foreign coins, slugs and other detritus.

A receipt then prints out the amount due, which can be brought to the customer service desk in exchange for cash. (Many locations will limit how much you can exchange; typically the maximum is $500 per visit.)

The upside to using Coinstar is that you don't have to count or sort your change. The downside is there is an 11.9% surcharge deducted from the total, plus a 25-cent fee per transaction.

So if you pour in $50 worth of loose change, you're only going to get $43.80 back in cash. The convenience may be worth the expense for you. But there's also a workaround: There's no service charge if you accept an eGift card instead of cash. You are limited in where you can spend your money, but participating retailers include Amazon, Domino's, The Gap,, Southwest Airlines, Stop & Shop, Starbucks, Steam, Home Depot and Nike. Typically the gift cards require depositing at least $5 or $10 in change and max out at $500.With Coinstar, you also have the option of donating some or all of your change to one of eight charities:

Florida-based Publix has more than 1,200 supermarkets across the Southeast US. While Publix doesn't have Coinstar machines, it does have its own coin sorter near the front door of every location.There is a 10% fee, but that's still lower than Coinstar's rate.

There's another, more altruistic reason to cash in your coins: While there is currently an adequate supply of coins in the economy, the Federal Reserve says circulation is still down from pre-pandemic levels.

Not only did business closures mean fewer coins changed hands, but many consumers got used to online shopping and contactless payments with credit cards, Apple Pay and Venmo.

The pandemic "has posed significant challenges for the US coin supply chain," according to the US Coin Task Force.

Kenneally of the American Bankers Association said the shortage is getting better but is still a problem, with dimes and quarters in particular in short supply.

"We encourage everyone to empty their piggy banks and pay merchants with exact change when they can," he added.

The US Mint, which was partially shut down during the pandemic, has told the ABA it's currently "maxed out" on coin production, Kenneally said.

The shortage is most likely to impact older and lower-income Americans who opt to pay with cash, rather than cards or digital payment apps.